मान, शिस्त आणि ताल… कुठे हरवला पुण्याचा गणेशोत्सव?

The echoes we are losing.

There was a time when Pune’s Ganesh Visarjan was not just a procession. It was a lesson. A tradition. A living heartbeat that carried history, discipline, devotion, and pride through the city’s streets. Today, as I watch the same procession unfold, I find myself asking a question that feels heavier with each passing year: What really changed? And when did we stop noticing?

For years, I saw Pune’s Ganesh Visarjan through Harshad’s eyes.

As someone who grew up in Mumbai, I knew Ganesh Chaturthi differently. The celebrations were grand, emotional, vibrant. But Pune’s culture was something I had to learn.

And Harshad loved teaching me.

Every year, as Anant Chaturdashi approached, there was a certain excitement in his voice. Whether standing on the streets or watching a live telecast at home, he would become that schoolboy again, proudly narrating stories I had never heard before.

“Do you know why this Ganpati comes first?”

“Do you know the history of the Manache Ganpati?”

“Listen carefully to the rhythm of the tasha.”

“Watch how the flag is carried.”

For him, these were not small details. They were traditions carrying generations of meaning.

He spoke about his years with the Jnana Prabodhini Pathak. About the discipline of the talim. About the honour attached to the dhwaj. About the powerful yet controlled energy of the dhol-tasha pathaks. About the garjana that had a protocol. About the final aarti offered only after the instruments were respectfully placed down.

Every ritual had a purpose. Every sound had dignity. Every step had discipline.

And while listening to him, I began to understand why Pune took such pride in its Visarjan Miravnuk.

Because it was never merely a celebration.

It was CULTURE IN MOTION.


This Year, Something Felt Different

This year too, we sat down to watch the live telecast.

The familiar sounds echoed through the screen.

The crowds were larger than ever.

The energy was undoubtedly high.

Yet something felt deeply unsettling.

As the hours went by, an uncomfortable silence grew between us.

The trolling. The clashes. The chaos. The competition. The desperate attempt to be seen. 🙁

At one point, I found myself looking at the television and wondering:

“Are people participating in a tradition, or performing for some audience?”

The question lingered.

Because somewhere amidst the noise, something precious seemed to have disappeared.


Well, not all pathaks are the same.

Many continue to uphold discipline, train rigorously, and preserve traditions with immense sincerity. Even today!

But alongside them, a different culture has emerged.

A culture where visibility often matters more than values. Where fame matters more than rhythm.

Where volume matters more than devotion. Where “being noticed” matters more than understanding what is actually being celebrated.

The irony is really painful.

The dhol was once a symbol of collective spirit. The tasha demanded practice, endurance, and synchronization. The pathak represented practice, commitment and discipline.

Today, many see it simply as an accessory.

A costume. A social media moment. And the difference shows.

Not in the decibel levels. But in the intent.


As the procession continued, I found myself having an imaginary conversation with the founders of the public Ganeshotsav movement.

“What did you envision when this started?”

Their answer, I imagine, would have been simple.

“One Ganpati. One community. One celebration.”

And then I look around today.

Every home wants its own Ganpati.

Every society wants its own Ganpati.

Every lane wants its own Ganpati.

Every area wants its own “King”… What started off only as a “Lalbaug cha Raja” today even has a “Bhugaon cha Maharaja”!

Every mandal wants its own spectacle.

Every group wants its own identity.

Every celebration wants to be bigger than the next.

Somewhere in this race, collective spirit has quietly given way to individual display.

Public celebrations were created to bring people together.

Yet today, the sheer scale sometimes feels as though everyone wants their own stage.


Perhaps what saddened me most was not the disorder.

Every large event faces challenges. I understand.

Every generation changes traditions in its own way. That is completely fine too.

What saddened me most was the growing distance from the very stories that oncemade these traditions meaningful.

Many can name the most popular mandals.

Many can recognise famous celebrity faces in pathaks.

Many can identify viral performances and hook steps.

But how many truly know the chronology of the Manache Ganpati?

How many know why certain honours exist?

How many know the significance of the rituals they participate in?

How many know the stories behind the pride?

Because when history is forgotten, symbolism becomes simply a decoration.

And when symbolism becomes decoration, tradition slowly transforms into spectacle. A show.


Maybe every generation believes things were better before.

Maybe nostalgia always paints the past in warmer colours.

Yet some concerns go beyond nostalgia.

They come from a genuine fear of losing something valuable.

Not the dhol. Not the tasha. Not the processions.

But the spirit behind them.

The discipline. The humility. The respect.

The sense that belonging to something larger than yourself is an honour, not a performance.

As the final stretches of the Visarjan passed before our eyes, I did not feel angry anymore.

I felt sad.

Sad for a tradition that once taught discipline through celebration.

Sad for a city whose pride came from its culture rather than its spectacle.

And sad because somewhere, beneath all the noise, I could still hear echoes of what Pune’s Ganesh Visarjan used to be.

The question is whether we can still hear them too. I hope sad does not shift to being “inert”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *